Prior Authorization Denied? An Appeal May Be Worth It

One of the biggest frustrations Medicare Advantage enrollees can face is learning that care recommended by their doctor has been denied by their health plan.
Many MA insurers use prior authorization, which requires approval before the plan covers certain medical services, procedures, or treatments. But enrollees who receive a denial may not realize that they have the right to appeal the decision — and that an initial denial is not necessarily the final word.
Recent research by Bloomberg News and KFF found that a significant share of appealed prior authorization denials is overturned. In light of those findings, MA enrollees who receive a denial may want to consider challenging the decision rather than simply giving up on recommended care.
Prior authorization has become a hot-button issue as patients and doctors complain that the requirements can delay medically recommended care and
create administrative headaches.
Health insurers say prior authorization helps prevent unnecessary or overly expensive care and control health care costs. However, criticism from patients, providers and policymakers has prompted efforts to streamline the process.
Federal regulators are also requiring greater transparency. MA insurers are now required to publicly report information about prior authorization approvals, denials, appeals, and response times.
Appeals can succeed
KFF's analysis of insurer data for 2025 found that MA insurers denied 12% of standard prior authorization requests. However, when enrollees or their providers appealed, 67% of those denials were overturned.
Results varied significantly by insurer. Among the large MA insurers KFF examined, Centene overturned 93% of appealed standard prior authorization denials, while Kaiser Permanente overturned 40%.
Despite those reversal rates, prior authorization denials are rarely appealed.
KFF noted that high reversal rates could mean an original request should have been approved or that the initial request lacked documentation necessary to justify the service. Either way, the findings show that an initial denial may not be the end of the process.
MA enrollees also have another important protection. If the health plan reviews an appeal and stands by its original denial, the case is automatically forwarded to an independent review entity that takes another look at the plan's decision.
What you can do
If your MA plan denies a prior authorization request, consider taking these steps:
Read the denial notice. Determine exactly why the request was denied and note the instructions and deadline for filing an appeal.
Contact your doctor. Your provider may be able to supply additional medical records, correct missing information or otherwise strengthen the request.
Contact your MA plan. Ask what coverage criteria and documentation were used to make the decision and what is required for an appeal.
File an appeal. Follow the procedures in the denial notice. Your doctor or another authorized representative may also be able to help with the appeal.
Ask for expedited consideration when appropriate. If waiting for a standard decision could seriously jeopardize your life, health or ability to regain maximum function, you may qualify for a faster review.
Understand the independent review process. If your plan upholds its denial, the case is automatically sent to an independent review entity.
Keep records. Retain denial notices, medical records, and appeal documents, and save conversations with your insurer and medical providers.
The takeaway
A Medicare Advantage prior authorization denial can be discouraging, particularly when your doctor believes the care is medically necessary. But don't assume that the plan's first decision is the last word.
With KFF finding that about two-thirds of appealed standard prior authorization denials were overturned, appealing may be worth considering. Follow the instructions in your denial notice and take advantage of the appeal and independent review rights available to MA enrollees.




Comments